TAA i.2.1.131
Confidential letter from Howard Carter to his solicitor Richard Bethell Molony regarding negotiations with the Egyptian Government, recounting events from 15 December 1924 – 16 January 1925, page 4.
Several people are mentioned on this page, including: George Merzbach Bey, Almina Herbert Countess Carnarvon, Sir John Maxwell, Abd el Hamid Bedawy Pasha, Pierre Lacau, 'Prime Minister' Ziwar Pasha, 'H.E. the Minister', and Mahmoud Bey Sidky.
© Griffith Institute,
University of Oxford
IV 129
“MOLONY JAPEN HOLB LONDON.
PROGRESS SLOW BUT GOVERNMENT PREPARED TO GRANT CONCESSION TILL
OCTOBER 1926 AGAINST RENUNCIATIONS AS MENTIONED LETTER MERZBACH
JUNE 29 STOP GOVERNMENT WILL BY SEPARATE LETTER UNDERTAKE GIVE
ALMINA SOME DUPLICATES AFTER COMPLETION WORK AS PER SIR JOHN
MAXWELL LETTER ELEVENTH MARCH STOP FURTHER INTERVIEW SUNDAY
WHEN HOPE IMPROVEMENT HOWARD.”
During the interim the local press have been active in launching
divers criticisms and attacks, the cause of delay in settlement
declared to be owing to "l’intransigeance de M. Carter".
As agreed Merzbach and I met Bedawy Pasha and Mr. Lacau 11am. Sunday
January 11th., at the Ministry of Public Works. From inner know-
ledge obtained, we gathered that instructions originating from high
sources had been issued to both Bedawy Pasha and Lacau to the effect
that every latitude should be shown to us, in fact we were to be
granted, onthesic lines already laid down, all that we reasonably asked,
but that interview suggested complete opposition to those instructions
on the part of Bedawy Pasha and Mr. Lacau. Here was the rub. How
to overcome the continued hostile feeling on the part of those two
people had been the crux of the whole situation. However, Merzq/<b>ach
quickly and cleverly closed the interview to enable us to get that
point home in the right source. I hope in the long run we shall wii/<n>.
Lacau says he is leaving for Upper Egypt on Thursday next and
Merzbach wants to get away if possible on Wednesday also for Upper
Egypt.
I lunched with Merzbach. He had arranged to see the Prime Minis-
ter some time that afternoon. At 3.30 we received the prospective
documents from the Ministry, viz:- the draft of my letter to the
Minister, and the draft of his reply embodying the question of duplicates
and the draft of the new concession. In all the three documents
there is a distinct improvement, in fact with the exception of small
details there/<y> were acceptable. We have without doubt gained at
least the principal part of our demands.
January 12th. noon we met Badawy Pasha amd Mr. Lacau at the Minis-
try of Public Works when the question of the wording of the two
letters and the concession was finally settled. Badawy Pasha pro-
mised to have the documents prepared for signature next day January
13th (see copies attached). At the termination of the interview
Merzbach and I called on the Minister of Public Works (Mahmoud Bey
Sidky) who was exceedingly courteous. If in the future we have to
deal with such gentlemen there should be no trouble whatsoever. H.
E. the Minister mentioned that they wanted me to go to Luxor immedia-
tely and commence work. He particularly requested me to go to Luxor
first, open the Tomb, and leave the unpacking of the mar/<t>erial here at
the Museum until the end of the season. I thanked him for all the
courtesy shown to me by the Egyptian Government, I said I would leave
for Luxor on Wednesday 14th., and we parted best of friends. Hence
our cable:-
“MOLONY JAPEN HOLB LONDON.
TO ALMINA AND ALL CONCERNED STOP WILL SIGN TOMORROW WEDNESDAY
NEW CONCESSION WHEREIN GOVERNMENT IS WILLING TO GIVE AT HIS DIS-
CRETION ALMINA A CHOICE OF DUPLICATES AS REPRESENTATIVE AS POS-
SIBLE OF DISCOVERY WHEREVER SUCH DUPLICATES CAN BE SEPARATED
FROM THE WHOLE WITHOUT DAMAGE TO SCIENCE STOP THIS MAXIMUM
REASONABLE IN MY OPINION STOP PLEASE REQUEST ALMINA AND EXECU-
TORS TO ATONCEsic RENOUNCE ANY CLAIM WHATSOEVER AGAINST GOVERNMENT
STOP PLEASE SEND CREDIT NATIONAL BANK LUXOR WORK TO PROCEED
AT ONCE STOP OUR HEARTIEST CONGRATULATIONS.
HOWARD MERZBACH.”